Southern Pecan Praline Scones (and an Ultimate Recipe Showdown follow-up)

I don’t know whether I was more surprised to be pronounced the winner of Ultimate Recipe Showdown: Cakes or to realize that my family actually kept the results a secret for almost 4 months.  Not one slip-up, and believe me, people tried to get it out of us.  My standard response was to say “It was a really great experience” paired with a look that said “It would be in your best interest to move on to a different subject now.”

Well, being a part of URS truly was a great experience.  Even before the results were announced, and I had already prepared myself to congratulate one of the other ladies, I had decided that I would gladly participate again if I am ever lucky enough to have the chance.  Or….say….if I’m lucky enough to be offered my own show (Sigh!  A girl can dream, can’t she?)  Just being able to spend time at the Food Network studios was a prize in itself.  Opportunities like being in the same kitchen as real live Food Network star Sunny Anderson and getting a behind-the-scenes perspective of how these shows really work were just icing on the cupcake (Ba-dum-bum!  Thank you, I’ll be here all night.)

Many people have asked me if it was hard to prepare my recipes in front of the judges and an audience while surrounded by cameras and crew.  Well….that’s not really how I do things at home, so it was definitely different.  The different kitchen and tools took a bit of getting used to, and the lights overhead added some heat (buttercream’s nemesis!)  I also kept apologizing to the camera guy because I spent what seemed like a lot of time chopping all of those pecans, and his camera looked too heavy to be recording something so repetitive and mundane.  Truthfully though, the first round was 4 hours long, so after my initial nerves wore off, I kind of just eased into full baking mode and did my thing.  Luckily, I was far enough away from the judges, so that I couldn’t hear much of their commentary, although I caught occasional words like “sweet potato” and knew that I was in the hot seat.  When I was working on some of the more difficult aspects of the recipe, such as adding the hot syrup for the buttercream or cutting even cake layers, yes, there was added pressure.  The generous 4 hours was great though.

When it came time for the speed round however, the pressure was alive and well.  Even though I had practiced my recipe over and over again at home within the 45-minute window, I knew that I had to remain focused.  I couldn’t forget any ingredients, so I needed to be meticulous, but I still needed to get my cupcakes into the oven in less than 10 minutes from the start.  The overhead lights were also a concern, as I knew that this might affect the cooling time of the cupcake and, as a result, the stability of the buttercream (thus the refrigeration of the buttercream.)   Note to self: IMG_0197 Next time I practice something like this at home, I am going to have Eric run around the kitchen making comments and yelling things like “Ladies, you have 10 minutes remaining!!!”

Standing in front of the judges, watching them eat your creations, ponder, take another bite…..this was the most nerve-wracking part, in my opinion.   Having Guy Fieri there next to me was really helpful.  He was great with the one-liners and comic relief.  And how about judge Katherine Alford’s “happy dance?”  I think that this might just be the next new dance craze.  And to think that it all started with a little cupcake…

Although I was obviously thrilled, and shocked, to win, I would have been happy for any of the ladies if they took the title.  I mean, I consider myself to be competitive, and winning is great, but the four of us spent quite a bit of time together, so there was a true sense of camaraderie among us by the end.  The only semi-bummer is that I found out my recipe will not be on the Friday’s menu, which is something that I was looking forward to.  That being said, I completely understand that decisions made by a big corporation like Friday’s are more complicated than a 45 minute cupcake, and these things sometimes happen.  I’m sure that they have a good reason.

In the event that you want to try either of my recipes at home, they are both posted on the Food Network website.  I sent some cupcakes into work with Eric yesterday, although it now makes me nervous to have people taste them.  I sure hope they think they’re worthy of the prize…  This is new to me, so it’s tough to look on the FN website and see reviews that say that more malt or more sugar is needed or that the cupcakes are “just O.K.”  Hey-I worked hard on those.  I sure wish that I could please everyone with my creations.  When I figure out how to do that, I’ll let you know.  That is definitely worth $25k!

One of the best things about my URS appearance was the number of long-lost friends who found me through my blog.  Some just happened to be watching the Food Network and they had a “Hey!  I know her!” moment.  Others found out from a friend of a friend or from something like Facebook (just joined–I can see how it can become an addiction.)  One such friend, Ellen, I hadn’t been in contact with for almost 2 years.  She was always a big fan of my Pecan Praline Scones, and she said that she had been unsuccessful in looking for a similar recipe on-line.  So Ellen, today’s recipe is dedicated to you.  These buttery, rich, and flaky scones should be a welcome morning treat up there in blustery cold Chicago (don’t you miss our 70 degree temps just a little bit???)  Enjoy, and it was so great to hear from you!  Here are a few extra tips for preparing perfect praline scones:IMG_0204

  • Because the praline pieces melt a bit while the scones are baking, some of them may seep around the bottom edges.  If this area starts to burn, you can either remove it with a knife or a spoon, or you can tent the scones loosely with foil for the remainder of the baking period.
  • The scone dough can be prepared 1 day in advance and refrigerated, tightly wrapped.  You can also pre-cut the scone shapes and freeze them.  Thaw in the refrigerator overnight and bake as directed.   Fully baked scones can also be frozen, tightly wrapped, for up to one week.  Thaw at room temperature and reheat.
  • If the scone dough is too dry after adding the buttermilk, then add a few tablespoons more.  The dough should be evenly moist, but not overly sticky and wet.  Be careful to not overwork the dough.  Overworked dough will result in tough, not light and flaky, scones.
  • I use a convection oven for baking these scones, which circulates the hot air and speeds up the baking process.  Depending on your oven, you might need to add a few minutes to the baking time.
  • These are LARGE scones.  Feel free to cut them in half to yield 2 dozen.

Southern Pecan Praline Scones

Makes 12 large scones


For the pralines

2 cups light brown sugar

1/4 cup whole milk

3 tablespoons unsalted butterIMG_0207

1 teaspoon vanilla

1/4 teaspoon ground cinnamon

1/8 teaspoon salt

1 1/2 cups chopped pecans

For the scones

4 cups flour

1/2 cup sugar

2 teaspoons baking powder

1 teaspoon baking soda

1/2 teaspoon salt

10 ounces cold unsalted butter, cut into pieces

1 1/3 cups buttermilk, plus more if needed

1 egg mixed with 2 tablespoons milk

Prepare the pecan pralines:  In a medium saucepan, combine the brown sugar, milk, butter, vanilla, cinnamon, and salt.  Bring the mixture to a boil over medium heat, stirring constantly so the sugar dissolves.  Add the chopped pecans to the mixture and continue to boil for 5 minutes, stirring occasionally.  Drop the mixture by heaping tablespoonfuls onto parchment-lined baking sheets; allow to cool completely.  When the pralines have hardened, break into small chunks or roughly chop.

Preheat the oven to 375F degrees.  Place oven racks in the upper and lower thirds positions.

Line 2 baking sheets with parchment paper.  In the work bowl of a food processor, combine the flour, sugar, baking powder, baking soda, and salt; pulse to combine.  Scatter the butter pieces over the flour mixture and pulse several times until the mixture resembles coarse meal.

Transfer the mixture to a large bowl and stir in the chopped praline pieces.  Add the buttermilk, mixing until just combined.  Turn the dough out onto a floured work surface and gently knead a few times to bring the dough together.  Divide the dough in half and pat it into two rounds, about 1-inch thick.  Cut each round into 6 wedges and place the wedges on the prepared baking sheets.  Brush the tops of the scones with the egg wash.  Bake the scones for 20-25 minutes, rotating positions halfway through the baking process, until they are golden brown and a toothpick inserted into the center emerges clean.


  1. says

    Hi Julie, it’s so funny you blogged about this subject today. I am watching the show right this second. I like baking, unfortunately I do not have the time to cook or bake as much as I’d like to but I will definitely try your recipes. Thanks much!

  2. says

    I just saw you present your cake and told my Honey, I know her from a blog, I think she’s Julie & peanut butter. It kept bothering me and so I googled you! And guess what I was right and on top of it you WON!! Awesome! Good for you…you go girl! congrats!

  3. Anissa says

    Unlucky me…I am in the company weight loss challenge and down 11 pounds! I restrained, but everyone that ate the cupcakes could not stop raving about them. We even had people come down from other properties to see if there were any left! I do have the recipe, so I will be baking some for PJ to take to work.

  4. says

    I was out of town when URS aired, but I DVR every episode. I would have had to cheer for you just because you’re from Las Vegas as well, but since I read your site it was even more exciting to cheer for you!

  5. says

    Last night was the first ever episode I saw of Ultimate Recipe Showdown. What fun!! Congrats to you. I too liked the happy dance one judge did! :)

  6. says

    I watched URS for the first time last night and was cheered to see a fellow blogger in the hunt for the prize. I’ve not been to your blog before but wanted to pop in and wish you congratulations on a well deserved win! Your sweet potato pecan cake looked spectacular! Will check the FN for your recipes. :)

    Thanks for sharing your experience, so interesting to read a behind the scenes account like this. And congrats again, Julie!

  7. says

    Congratulations!! It was so fun to watch!! I just finished it (thank you Tivo!) and I happen to LOVE MALT so I was so excited to watch you compete with that!! I can’t wait to try them!!

  8. says

    I forgot to add this: I make a chicken recipe that my friends and family love, it’s always good, and the one time I posted it on a recipe site the first comment was “it was just ok, it could have been better.” Go figure. You have impressed many of us, the rest just don’t know what they are missing!

  9. April says

    Congratulations on your win! I can’t wait to try them tomorrow! They are so blasted cute too! One question… you have a slightly different recipe on your blog from last summer than the one posted on the Food Network site. Which do you prefer with the cherry buttercream?

  10. says

    Thanks, April!

    I guess that it all depends on whether you prefer chocolate or vanilla cupcakes with the cherry buttercream. I personally think that chocolate and cherry are a better pairing, but I think that the malt flavor comes through a bit more with the vanilla (chocolate is stronger). That being said, you can always increase the amount of malt if you like a more pronounce malt flavor. I hope this helps! Let me know if you have any more questions.


  11. Katrina says

    I saw the Recipe showdown on Food network and saw your chocolate malt cupcake recipe. I’m having a hard times trying to navigate the site. I wanted to know if you had the recipe on here?

  12. Colonial says

    Congrats on your URS win! It’s a shame that Friday’s opted not to put the cupcakes on the menu — my wife and I went to our local Friday’s earlier this week just to try it! My wife opted to get another URS winner on the menu — the mac-n-cheese. Let’s just say it tasted much better as a cold, day-after leftover than at Friday’s. Even as leftovers if was blah.

  13. says

    Congratulations on the win! I’ve crossed your blog once or twice before, but when I heard you say you had a blog on the show I was reminded of it and will now be checking in often. Both your cake and cupcakes looked fantastic and I’ve already printed out the recipes for my collection. :) Congrats again!

  14. April says

    So your cupcakes were a hit! I couldn’t find the espresso powder, so I had to leave it out, but they still turned out yummy! Fortunately it was cold here yesterday (we often can’t make an all butter buttercream here)so the buttercream held up really nicely. And I loved that my 4 year old could help by putting the whoppers on top (I think she may have ate a few too).
    Thanks Julie!!!!

  15. says

    Julie…congratulations on your win!! That is so very exciting! I know what you mean about being nervous when people try a winning recipe…but I am sure your cakes are fabulous and I can’t wait to try!

  16. says

    The recipe looks really good. Scones with pralines are really yummy. I’ve made a few recipes with pralines and they always make a great compliment to any food.

    Ms Recipe

  17. says

    Hi Julie! I saw your episode of URS and had to pop in to say hi! Congratulations! I’d love to be on the show some day, mostly to meet Guy, I admit! I’m a huge fan! 😀

    I’m definitely going to try both of your recipes soon!

  18. says

    Julie! Great job on URS, and thanks for posting the behind-the-scenes stuff. My husband always laughs at me when I watch a cooking contest on TV and say, “I know her! Well, I haven’t actually met her, but I know her!.” And you even got to plug your blog! Congrats!

    You were so pretty and poised on TV that it’s not crazy for you to dream of your own show. How about The Next Food Network Star? That’s how Guy got his start, after all.

    And I’m so making those scones for Mardi Gras. They look delicious.

  19. Ellen says

    Hi Julie, Thanks so much for the scone recipe. I can’t wait to make them. After all, they still are my favorite scone. Congratz again on winning URS. Maybe you can meet up with Karen and me for coffee when I come to town. It would be great to see you again. I mean, before you become the Next Food Network Star!!!

    Take Care, Ellen

  20. says

    I was so impressed with your appearance on the show with your fabulous recipe. That is how I found your blog. Thanks for sharing your recipes and even though this is a bit belated, congratulations! janet in nc

  21. says

    Hi Julie, I was really glad that I’ve found your blog. I was looking for a wonderful recipe to prepare this weekend because my friends are coming. And, I am now excited to make this recipe. It’s perfect and easy.

  22. Louise says

    Oooo! Pecan pralines and scones in one! I found your blog by following a trail from this sweet collection on Sugar Rush! Good thing I found them in time to celebrate Mardi Gras! Thanks!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>